Votes
Be the first member to cast a vote on this battle!
Community Verdict
This was an incredibly close and debatable battle, with fan opinion split almost down the middle. However, a slight majority of comments give the edge to Illmac, primarily due to his creative angles, impactful rebuttals, and a show-stealing second round. While Soul's third round is considered by many to be the best of the battle, Illmac's overall consistency and memorable moments carried him to a narrow victory in the court of public opinion.
The long-awaited international clash between USA's Illmac and Scotland's Soul on Premier Battles wasn't just a battle; it was a lyrical spectacle that more than lived up to the hype. Hailed by fans as an instant classic and a clear battle-of-the-year contender for 2018, this matchup showcased two of the sharpest pens in the game operating at peak performance. The energy from the UK crowd was electric from the jump, providing the perfect backdrop for the high-level writing on display.
Illmac brought a veteran's poise, blending creative angles, character breakdowns, and sharp rebuttals. His second-round 'air traffic controller' scheme became an instant-classic moment, a perfect mix of humor and direct attack that many felt sealed the battle. Soul countered with his signature dense, multi-syllabic rhyme schemes, particularly in a breathtaking third round that fans called one of the best of the year.
The battle became a razor-close affair, a debate of preference between Illmac's targeted creativity and Soul's relentless lyrical assault. While the consensus leans narrowly toward Illmac, the true winner was the culture, which received a timeless battle with endless replay value.
- The battle was universally praised as a 'classic' and a top contender for 'Battle of the Year'.
- Fans lauded the high level of writing from both emcees, celebrating it as a premier showcase for lyrical talent.
- Illmac's second round, especially the 'air traffic controller' angle, was frequently singled out as a genius performance.
- The energetic and appreciative UK crowd was consistently credited with elevating the atmosphere of the entire event.
- Soul's third round was widely regarded as a phenomenal display of intricate writing and performance.
- A common sentiment was that the battle is 'criminally underviewed' and deserves a much larger audience for its quality.
- Several comments noted that the crowd's early reactions sometimes disrupted Soul's momentum, forcing him to restart complex schemes.
- Some viewers pointed out technical critiques with the production, such as differing frame rates between camera angles.
- A few fans found the audible laughter and reactions from the crew behind the camera to be distracting at times.
Related Battles
Chat
Members Only
Log in to view the chat and share your thoughts on this matchup.