KOTD: King of the Dot Calgary, Alberta, Canada Apr 6, 2012

Tricky PvsCharron

129.7K
Views

AI Verdict

Verdict
Winner
95% confidence
Score
21

Based on overwhelming fan sentiment, Charron secured a clear victory through a masterful display of freestyling and rebuttals. His ability to flip Tricky P's material in real-time, particularly the now-legendary 'Burns to Smithers' Simpsons line, was the defining factor. While Tricky P was highly entertaining, especially in his third round, Charron's consistent, hard-hitting, and off-the-dome bars demonstrated a higher level of battle readiness and control.

Round-by-Round
Charron immediately set the tone with a barrage of on-point rebuttals, including a well-received Big L scheme. Tricky P had a slight choke in his intro and, while delivering a characteristically high-energy performance, was outmaneuvered by Charron's elite freestyling from the jump.
This round was sealed by what many fans call one of the greatest rebuttals of all time: the 'It burns to Smithers' flip. The line received a massive reaction and completely took the wind out of Tricky's sails. Charron's dominance with off-the-top material was undeniable here.
While Charron remained consistent, Tricky P created the most memorable and bizarrely entertaining moment of the battle. His extended, nonsensical, and comedic freestyle, culminating in revealing his blue hair, was a spectacle that won over the crowd through pure showmanship, even if it lacked traditional punches.
Analysis

In a battle that prioritized pure entertainment and top-tier freestyling over aggression, Charron delivered a career-defining performance against his friend and former 2-on-2 partner, Tricky P. From the opening round, the Ottawa native put on a rebuttal clinic, dismantling Tricky's bars with a speed and cleverness that left the crowd in awe. His legendary 'Burns to Smithers' flip in the second round became an instant KOTD classic and effectively sealed the deal.

Tricky P, for his part, brought his signature unorthodox flow and charismatic stage presence. Despite a slight stumble at the start, he held his own and refused to be completely run over. His third round was a spectacle of performance art, a bizarre and hilarious extended freestyle that showcased his unique brand of entertainment, even if it conceded the lyrical victory.

While Charron's pen and off-the-dome prowess were too sharp to overcome, the battle is remembered as a fun, respectful classic that showcased two of KOTD's most unique talents at their best.

01Charron's 'It burns to Smithers' rebuttal in the second round, a clever flip of a Simpsons reference.
02Tricky P's wild, extended freestyle in the third round, where he abandoned written bars for a long, comedic, and stream-of-consciousness performance.
03Charron opens his first round with a multi-bar rebuttal scheme dismantling Tricky P's Big L reference.
04Charron lands his 'Getting head in the box like Brad Pitt in Se7en' punchline, which gets a strong reaction.
What fans loved
  • Charron's godly rebuttal ability and freestyling.
  • The 'Burns to Smithers' Simpsons flip, considered an all-time great rebuttal.
  • Tricky P's hilarious and entertaining third-round freestyle.
  • The fun, respectful, and comedic energy between the two battlers.
  • The overall high entertainment value of the matchup.
Criticisms
  • Tricky P seemed unprepared for unlimited rounds.
  • Tricky P's third round was viewed as 'nonsense' or giving up by some.
  • The battle felt more like a comedy show than a lyrical clash to certain viewers.
  • Tricky P's slight choke in his intro.
  • Charron's attempt to use a DNA angle from the Dizaster battle was seen as a misstep.

Chat

Members Only

Log in to view the chat and share your thoughts on this matchup.